Home » Blog Row, The Water Cooler

Murder They Wrote: Banners by Religious Groups Incite Violence

By 25 February 2011 5 Comments

A banner posted in Karachi by a religious group calls for the death of author Tehmina Durrani. Photo:

A banner posted in Karachi by a religious group calls for the death of author Tehmina Durrani. Photo: Zaheer A. Kidvai

(Yet Another) Hate-mongering Alert:

Across Karachi are banners asking for Tehmina Durrani to be hanged.

Who has issued this call? Yet another ‘tehreek.’ This time it is one that calls itself the Tehreek-Tahafuz-e-Tableegh-e-Islam.

It takes offence to “a book written by Tehmina Durrani” in which she has allegedly slandered God’s Auliyas and Ulemas. The obvious reference seems to be to her book, Blasphemy, which deals with the exploitation of women at the hands of pirs – a certain pir and the way the supposed religious figure victimises the women of his household and community.

For anybody to deny that there are such ‘religious men’ who victimise and molest women and children would be atrocious. This, of course, does not mean that every such personality in this country does so. Still, there are those who do, and they get away with it. So hang them if there is anyone that should be hanged; however, the capital punishment debate is another one.

Misconstruing and misrepresenting the words of others seems to have become a favourite pastime of these ‘tehreeks,’ as has their zealous demand to hang people. (I’m sure they would much prefer to strike it off the Taliban way). And many people have cried themselves hoarse objecting to similar pamphlets and banners that spread lies about people and invite others to vehemently denounce, if not kill, them. And since there seems to be no shortage of Qadris or supporters of the likes of him, there is a very real possibility that this hate will result in another death.

What is anyone doing about this? Sadly, that is another tragic story. The people who have the power to do something lack the will, and those that have the will lack the power. If only ‘someone’ would state strongly that the lives of people will not be threatened and any person or organisation to do so will face dire consequences. But that call doesn’t come.

This article has not been written because the life of Tehmina Durrani, specifically, has been threatened. It is certainly not a protest to the life of an influential or a member of the elite being threatened. It is, however, a protest against threats made against the lives of people, human beings, who are the victims of such extremism. The masses, especially those that belong to the lower socio-economic groups, face the brunt of it all. It is their houses that are burned down. They are the ones hacked, stoned or tortured to death, and it is they who have to flee for their lives and live like refugees in their own country since they don’t have the facility of jumping on a plane and leaving.

Farieha Aziz is a Karachi-based journalist and teacher. She joined Newsline in 2007, rising to assistant editor. Farieha was awarded the APNS award for Best Investigative Report (Business/Economic) for the year 2007-2008. She has a masters in English from the University of Karachi. Find her on twitter @FariehaAziz.

Find more articles by
The opinions expressed in this article and the views shared by readers in the comment forum below do not necessarily reflect the editorial stance or policies of Newsline.

Share this post:

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...


  • Zakintosh said:

    The signs started near the Airport, moved into PECHS, then to DHA, and now are at I I Chundrigar Road. How can people put up these signs? It takes a while to get them up, tie up ropes, make sure they are hung well … all in absolutely open, see-able spaces. Where is the Police? Why wouldn’t they stop people from putting these signs up … or remove them once they are up? And if they did get permissions, who signed those?

    I think it is the right of the people of the city to ask Police and City leaders to have all of these and similar signs removed and never be allowed up again. Any organization that supports such signs should be asked to remove them immediately … including banners that talk about Qadri or Aasiya or others while the case is in progress. That’s legal. It can be done. Let’s start!

  • Farieha Aziz (author) said:

    I agree. They have been up far too long and have spread to far too many places. They need to be taken down immediately.

    The concerned authorities should take them down themselves, but since expecting them to initiate action on their own against hate speech, incitement to violence, murder and vigilantism would be expecting too much, they must to be approached and made to do so.

  • Bilal Zubedi said:

    Its spreading like the Australian bush fires. Hatred and intolerance is rampant. Now they are asking for someone else to be killed. The intolerant extremists must be taken to task. The government is silent since the inception of Pakistan and the law seemingly on the side of the extremist minds. Opprobrious and disgusting.

  • HIna said:

    These “haters” are nothing but a group of criminal minded lot, who think they can create a place for themselves in the world by playing on the emotional aspects of our people – vote cashers – that’s their ultimate agenda – we need to prove that we are more educated and beyond their disgusting minds – by not letting such people have a say at all !!!!!

    Promoting hate speeches should be part of breaking the law – perhaps we need to revise our legal clauses related to this subject.

  • Farieha Aziz (author) said:

    It is a tragic day. Another life has been lost. Minister for Minority Affairs, Shahbaz Bhatti was shot dead earlier today in Islamabad. When does this stop?