Home » Blog Row, The Water Cooler

Mukhtar Mai to Seek Review of Judgement

By 23 April 2011 4 Comments

Law-02-11There has been a lot of debate and discussion about the recent Supreme Court decision in the Mukhtaran Mai case. Several rights groups and individuals have voiced their disappointment. And now, Mukhtar Mai’s legal counsel, Aitzaz Ahsan, via a written statement, has publicly voiced his. The respected lawyer has some strong criticisms. In it, he alleges, “The majority judgment is manifestly flawed and, in material particulars, is not even based on the evidence available on the record.”

As such, he declares that “I have consulted with Mukhtar Mai, and we have decided that a petition seeking review of the judgement of 21st April will be filed soon. The petition will contain a full critique of the judgement.”

Below is the text of the press release that he sent to Newsline earlier this afternoon:

PRESS RELEASE

April 23, 2011

MUKHTAR MAI CASE

STATEMENT OF MR. AITZAZ AHSAN
Sr. Advocate Supreme Court
Advocate for the Appellant

I am deeply disappointed by the 21st April majority judgment of the Supreme Court dismissing the appeals filed by the gang-rape victim, Mukhtar Mai.

The majority judgment is manifestly flawed and, in material particulars, is not even based on the evidence available on the record. In drawing their conclusions, the learned majority judges have disregarded cogent evidence and failed to notice actual material on the records and the facts proved thereby. They have also misread the evidence that they have adverted to. The learned judges have also failed to take notice of the social backdrop, which was established on the record itself, and in the context of which the horrendous crime of gang-rape was committed, reported and investigated. The decision of the majority needs to be reviewed and recalled.

I have consulted with Mukhtar Mai, and we have decided that a Petition seeking Review of the Judgment of 21st April will be filed soon.

The Petition will contain a full critique of the judgment. Hence there is no need for me to make any other comments in the media on the subject.

We are grateful to the people, the media, civil society and particularly the women of Pakistan for their committed support in this critical hour.

Aitzaz Ahsan


Talib Qizilbash has been freelance writing since 2003. He joined Newsline in 2006, working as both a writer and editor, and has won a national APNS award for his writing. As online editor, he led the overhaul and re-launch of the magazine's website from 2009-2012. Find him on twitter @tqizilbash.


Find more articles by
The opinions expressed in this article and the views shared by readers in the comment forum below do not necessarily reflect the editorial stance or policies of Newsline.

Share this post:



1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...

4 Comments »

  • Sultan Khan said:

    When Mukhtaran Mai has already said that now she has no faith in courts and that she has submitted her case in the Court of Almighty then why she is filing the review petition.Again she will receive the same verdict.However, the chances of reversal are there only if some other bench hears the case.

  • Mohammad said:

    Well, there you have it!

    “Independent judiciary”…the law of evidence: by which Pakistanis are held hostage…

  • Saad said:

    Aitzaz should quit now I remember when Mukhtaran met the CJP then deposed and what they said Shame on them

  • How The Pakistani Legal System Subverted Justice « Jayati Vora said:

    [...] columns of outrage over the verdict. And Mai’s lawyer, the well-known Barrister Aitzaz Ahsan, has issued a statement that they will [...]