Attack on PNS Mehran Reveals the Rot Within Pakistan
Under attack, again: Flames and smoke rise up into the night sky in Karachi as another Pakistani military installation comes under attack on May 22, 2011. Photo: courtesy AJE / EPA
One of the first mentions I saw on Twitter about the deadly attacks on two Karachi military installations on May 22 was from popular twitterer @Ali_Abbas_Zaidi.
I first saw this tweet of his:
Despite his minor typo at the end (it should have read Orion, instead of Onion), this tweet by Mr Zaidi is another example of the value and importance of Twitter in modern news reporting. It seems Mr Zaidi beat the big national news channels in obtaining information on the damaged aircraft. That tweet by Mr Zaidi was some time around (perhaps just before) 11pm. But actually, five tweets earlier and a few minutes before, he had already mentioned the damaged military aircraft:
So, at the time, while the type of damage was unclear, it was clear that unknown militants had managed to infiltrate a military base in Karachi and damage a multi-million-dollar piece of machinery. Throughout the night, Mr Zaidi continued to tweet valuable insights about the events because of his sources within the Navy (former classmates). From elsewhere too, the tweets and news reports kept pouring in: more bomb blasts, ongoing firing, big plumes of smoke, the need for blood donations. Besides the obvious dismay of another round of heartbreaking attacks in Pakistan (and the shock of another GHQ-style attack), a multitude of questions popped up: how big was the blast, how many people have been hurt and killed, how many attackers were there, was this an inside job and was the P-3C Orion the main target and why?
Here’s how Lockheed Martin, the US defence contractor and aviation manufacturer who builds the Orion, describes their aircraft:
The P-3 Orion is a peerless airborne hunter. Its reputation as the ultimate submarine finder was earned through more than 45 years of service, from the Cuban Missile Crisis to round-the-clock, patrols throughout the Cold War. With 435 aircraft in the worldwide fleet, the P-3 remains a relied-upon asset today and has proven to be remarkably well adapted for maritime patrol and support in recent world events including Operation Unified Assistance in Southeast Asia, Hurricane Katrina and the BP Horizon oil rig disaster in the U.S. No other aircraft is better suited for these missions.
The P-3 Orion is operated by 21 governments and agencies in 17 nations.
According to Wikipedia, it has a price tag of $36 million.
The Pakistan Navy ordered upgraded P-3 models (equipped with airborne early warning systems) from the US in 2006. These upgraded P-3Cs were delivered in early 2007 and 2010. The two planes delivered in 2010 from the US were formally inducted into the Pakistan Navy fleet at PNS Mehran (the site of the May 22 attacks) and are reported to possess anti-ship and submarine warfare capabilities with a large “bomb bay” to house missiles and torpedoes.
In essence these aircraft are for maritime patrolling. And so the situation raises further questions.
The terrorists ripping Pakistan asunder do not attack the country by sea. They come from within. They roam the mountainous regions that straddle Pakistan and Afghanistan. They have sprawling compounds in Muridke and brainwash young minds in the madrassahs of South Punjab. They have training camps in the lawless tribal areas and are said to be hiding out in the capital of the troubled province of Balochistan, Quetta.
Why would they target aircraft at PNS Mehran that are designed to protect the country from a different enemy? And if this type of aircraft has the capability to carry nuclear missiles, wouldn’t militants with their eyes on Pakistan’s nuclear prize want to keep some of these assets around? What is the importance of focusing on an aircraft that does not seem to directly threaten them?
Of course, everything seems to threaten the militants living among us: girls’ schools, public markets, Muharram processions, peaceful Ahmedis and politicians who stand up for minorities.
This could be another symbolic hit: an attack that targets the military men and equipment which have ties to the US. It could be an Al-Qaeda-type message to Pakistan to stop partnering with the West. But perhaps it is simply another sign of the brutal reality of the ideology of the Pakistani Taliban and other associated militant groups? Weaken the government, rattle the military and terrorise the people through violence. It has been proven over the years that the Taliban and its ilk will attack any military installation, any government installation and any public area in an effort to weaken, kill and intimidate. Why else would they continue to attack Navy installations? The work of sailors and those who guard Pakistan’s coast have nothing to do with the Taliban holed up across the land, yet in late April militants also targeted three buses killing several Navy personnel and injuring dozens more. Still, at this point, these reasons for this attack are purely speculative.
It is inevitable, though, that this paradox will get many commentators wondering about a foreign hand. It seems like it is already being hinted at. Shahzad Chaudhry, a defence analyst, told Express 24/7 (see video below) that the nation has to be careful about the intent of the attackers: “On whose behest are they undertaking such operations is something we need to be very worried about.”
For now, everyone should be very worried about the “how.” How did the attackers breach security and easily reach the location of these aircraft in another very sensitive and heavily guarded military installation?
Of course, at this point, it is too early to say anything in-depth about the how, the who or the why. So while Twitter provides us with what is on the surface (the whats and the wheres), and often gives us many impartial news sources, we still have trouble digging out the truth. Unfortunately, these mysteries are rarely resolved in Pakistan. One thing is for sure, though: something is terribly rotten in the state of Pakistan. There are holes and leaks and moles and radical freaks throughout the country: in the mountains, in the cities and within the nation’s centres of power. Things could not be this bad (and continue to worsen) if it were not so.
Click play to watch the video from Express 24/7:
The opinions expressed in this article and the views shared by readers in the comment forum below do not necessarily reflect the editorial stance or policies of Newsline.
Share this post:
(No Ratings Yet)
Loading ...
It smells of plans that the nation’s security establishment needs to be closing in on by now.
The attack could be to show the strength & determination of Terrorist Organisations & it’s commanders. It could be to show or build terrorist organisations reputation of threat.
The terrorists organisations may not have considered importance of Pak’s security infrastructure to defend itself or the terrorists organisations want Pak water route un-secured to enter or run-away.
The Afghan drug syndicates who have connections, business interests & resources could be behind this attack.
India would not intend for the simple reason to save it’s goodwill & fear of retaliatory covert actions.
India may not have the necessary influence and bond of trust with terrorists organisations to attack Pak Navy.
It’s a coordinated attack planned by RAW in collaboration with CIA. It’s very much connected with the Abbotabad Operation, Raymond Davis release and terrorists attacks in Quetta. On May 16,2011 a Saudi diplomat was also gunned down by men on a motorbike as he drove through Karachi in Pakistan, just days after two hand grenades were lobbed at the consulate building, police say.
Read more: day earlier Obama said that America will land her forces to target her enemies in Pakistan. In fact American’s ultimate aim is to target Pakistan nuclear assets. Thus, Indian Intelligence agency has launched this operation to pave American agenda of hitting Pakistan first covertly and then overtly. Hitting Pakistan security forces clearly indicate that CIA, RAW and Mosssad are in actions. i would also like to suggest to my political leadership specially Imran Khan and others political and religious leadership to raise the voice against local traitors and stop encouraging those elements innocently who are in fact towing American agenda of increasing instability in Pakistan through fomenting terrorism . At the same time our security forces has to remove their lapses. The government should provide the funds to the security insinuations because hitting of security establishment is other wise a stab in the back of Pakistan’s economy and security.
It’s a coordinated attack planned by RAW in collaboration with CIA. It’s very much connected with the Abbotabad Operation, Raymond Davis release and terrorists attacks in Quetta. On May 16,2011 a Saudi diplomat was also gunned down by men on a motorbike as he drove through Karachi in Pakistan, just days after two hand grenades were lobbed at the consulate building, police say.
Read more: day earlier Obama said that America will land her forces to target her enemies in Pakistan. In fact American’s ultimate aim is to target Pakistan nuclear assets. Thus, Indian Intelligence agency has launched this operation to pave American agenda of hitting Pakistan first covertly and then overtly. Hitting Pakistan security forces clearly indicate that CIA, RAW and Mosssad are in actions. i would also like to suggest to my political leadership specially Imran Khan and others political and religious leadership to raise the voice against local traitors and stop encouraging those elements innocently who are in fact towing American agenda of increasing instability in Pakistan through fomenting terrorism . At the same time our security forces has to remove their lapses. The government should provide the funds to the security insinuations because hitting of security establishment is other wise a stab in the back of Pakistan’s economy and security.
Those who never accepted Pakistan are trying their level best to destabilize it. The government should take all measures \NOW\ to bring these terrorists and their supporters to justice.
pakistan needs emergency measures to safe gaurd our national interests.present so called democratic govt is fully disable to face the crises,pakistan facing now.Attacks on our defense assets remind us the threat to our nuclear weapons.Americans frm now raising fingures to our security systems and our inability as they publicly objected our incapability in past.though present govt: issued more than 7000 visas to CIA operatives in pakistan without consulting ISI.THESE 7000 operatives recruited locals to collect information about taliban’s hideouts and our security complexes.US playing dual game with us .they are forcing forces to speed up operations in FATA ,on other side CIA OPERATIVEs infiltrate into underoperation areas through locals to convince them against state of pakistan.Another soft area for these operatives to work are drone affectees.This is brutal tool have been used against pakistan as suicide bombers.Our govt top political leaders played role which they were asigned by US.According to islamic traditions martyrs doesnot need revenge it is akind of blessing frm Allah so how could one beleive in pakistani talibans claim .it is a game to divide pakistan and US playing a leading role in this game.why afghan talibans did not claim as pakistani taliban doing!
No court, no verdict, no justice. Only propaganda from all sides. Good job everyone. There is no living in bubble, US is coming accept it and plan on.
Location of PNS Mehran in Karachi Pakistan Attacked by Terrorists and Pakistani Taliban
http://edharti.com/articles/1608/1/Location-of-PNS-Mehran-in-Karachi-Pakistan-Attacked-by-Terrorists-and-Pakistani-Taliban/Page1.html
For all those who say India or its intelligence agency is behind this attack let me answer ur comment with a simple fact. Acc. to wikileaks published a few days, fmr NSA of Pakistan Mr. Durrani himself admitted to fmr us ambassador of US Ms. Anne Pattieson that contrary to belief he knows that India is not behind the incidents that are happening in Balochistan
What I don’t understand is why no one is questioning the number of terrorists? At first, it was reported that there were 10-15 of them. Now, they are saying that all of them were killed and there were only 4? I fail to understand this contradiction. If there were only 4, how were they able to lay down a 14-hour siege and why weren’t the 2000 commandos etc able to overpower them sooner? If there were 15, what happened to the rest of the 11?
well said Mr. Zaheerul Hassan..very well said….Indian (RAW), americans (CIA) and jews (Mossad) are brutally destabilizing Pakistan…it’s high time that my indian friends accept this very bitter truth…which infact is, what’s been happening since post ’65 war era….or else my country/country-men would not have been facing this difficult time…
let alone our corrupt civil/military leaders who sold themselves at that time to pave the way, for these enemies to accomplish their cruel and demonic cause…
Follow Us
Search by Keyword
Search by Author
Powered by Authors WidgetLatest Poll
Blogroll
Blog Row
Media Partners
Blogs from Pakistan and Around the World
Top Search Terms
Recent Comments
Most Read...